|
|
|---|
John S Posts:1 2007-04-27 06:23:22 |
Would you give up Michael Young for Garrett Atkins? |
|---|---|
| I currently have Eric Chavez at third, and Orlando Cabrera is a free agent so he'd be my natural replacement if this deal was to be done.
Would you do it? J.J Hardy is available, but i'm hesitant on him. I'm thinking he just had a great week. Khalil Greene is also available But i like Cabrera because he's good for 25 steals a year. My team lacks speed, only ichiro is goign to get me steals |
| ronald g Posts:2 2007-04-27 06:29:42 |
|---|
| Yes, as long as Cabrera is available. |
| Grove Posts:1 2007-04-27 06:30:07 |
|---|
| I would. Young is great, but Cabrera as a replacement is not that bad. I think your team would be better with Atkins/Cabrera than Young/Chavez. Something is wrong with Chavez and he is terrible the past couple seasons. Atkins is still underrated...I don't know \why. |
| Adam G Posts:2 2007-04-27 06:31:17 |
|---|
| Absolutely, Michael Young is a great average hitter, but the power and RBIs that made him an elite SS two years ago has shrunk. Garrett Atkins is an elite 3B, much better than Chavez on many levels. His power is great, he will hit more than 30 Hr and 130 RBI this year. Im not sold on OC as a SS though, is JJ Hardy available he might be a more attractive option for you. Just some thoughts, good luck! |
