|
|
|---|
quicksilver2592 Posts:2 2007-04-28 06:41:24 |
Is this a fair trade? |
|---|---|
| I Give Ian Kinsler and I get Garret Atkins
|
| lethebikesin Posts:1 2007-04-28 06:47:23 |
|---|
| no. kinsler is in great form and is a beast at the moment. Also, you should look at their teams. Atkins plays for the lowly rockies, meaning less men on base which results in less possible RBI's for him. Kinsler is atleast on the Rangers. |
| Dan T Posts:1 2007-04-28 06:49:43 |
|---|
| i say that its a pretty good trade cuz atkins is going to get better as the season goes along and kinsler keeps making errors |
| Johnny Conservative Posts:1 2007-04-28 09:10:26 |
|---|
| I think it is a fairly even trade, although I am not sure I would pull the trigger if I were you. |
| RedSoxin07 Posts:1 2007-04-28 10:03:18 |
|---|
| This trade is fine. Kinsler is good- great right now- but Atkins has more of a track record. The Rockies lineup is not bad, either. Batting with quick Willy Taveras, Matt Holliday, and Todd Helton will provide opportunities for runs and RBI. I'm not convinced Kinsler will be great over the course of the entire season, but 2nd base is thinner than 3rd, so Kinsler might be more valuable even with slightly worse stats. |
